Introduction: A Stunning Withdrawal
FirstRand, South Africa’s most valuable banking group with a market capitalisation of approximately $26 billion, has announced it will seek an “orderly ownership transition” from its UK operations following a regulatory bombshell that has cost the lender nearly $1 billion . The decision marks a stunning withdrawal from one of the world’s most competitive financial markets and serves as a cautionary tale for African firms expanding into highly regulated Western jurisdictions .
The bank raised its provision for mis-sold UK motor finance claims to £750 million (approximately $993 million) after the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) finalised its redress scheme for an industry-wide scandal involving undisclosed commission payments to car dealers . FirstRand called the scheme “disproportionate and unfair,” arguing that the financial impact far exceeded the group’s expectations and wiped out more than a decade of profits from its UK motor finance operations .
The Motor Finance Scandal: What Happened
The Core Issue
The scandal centres on commission arrangements between lenders and car dealers between 2007 and 2024 . Dealers were paid commissions by lenders for arranging vehicle finance, but these commissions were often not fully disclosed to customers. In some cases, the commissions were as high as 55% of the total charge for credit .
📢 GET A DETAILED ARTICLES + JOBS
Join ASJ's WhatsApp Channel and never miss a post or opportunity.
The UK Court of Appeal initially ruled against lenders in October 2024. However, FirstRand successfully appealed to the UK Supreme Court, which largely overturned key parts of the Court of Appeal’s ruling while upholding one “unfair relationship” finding .
The FCA Redress Scheme
In October 2025, the FCA proposed a redress scheme to compensate affected consumers . Under the final scheme announced in late March 2026, 12.1 million loans are eligible for compensation, and the industry is expected to pay £7.5 billion (approximately R170 billion) to consumers .
The FCA said the average redress payment will be £829 per customer . The total cost of the programme, including operating expenses, is estimated at £9.1 billion .
FirstRand’s Financial Hit: The Numbers
Provisions Raised to £750 Million
FirstRand had initially set aside a much smaller provision. However, following the finalisation of the FCA’s scheme, the bank was forced to raise an additional £510 million (approximately R11.9 billion) . This brought the total accounting provision to £750 million (approximately R17.7 billion) .
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Total Provision | £750 million ($993 million) |
| Additional Provision (April 2026) | £510 million ($650 million) |
| Initial Provision | £240 million ($300 million) |
| Decade of UK Motor Finance Profit | £275 million ($350 million) |
| Purchase Price of Aldermore (2017) | £1.1 billion |
Profits Wiped Out
The scale of the provision is particularly striking when compared to the group’s historical earnings from the business. Over a decade of UK motor finance operations, FirstRand generated just £275 million (approximately $350 million) in profits . The current provision is almost three times the profit the group extracted from motor finance activities during that period .
FirstRand had paid £1.1 billion to acquire Aldermore in 2017 . The provision is now nearly as large as the acquisition price.
Impact on Group Earnings
FirstRand now expects its full-year normalised earnings to contract between 4% and 9% after the motor provision . Return on equity will be at or just below the bottom-end of its stated range of between 18% to 22% .
Despite the significant hit, FirstRand maintained that it would still be able to pay dividends, even under worst-case scenarios .
Why FirstRand Is Exiting: “Disproportionate and Unfair”
The Bank’s Objections
FirstRand has been scathing in its criticism of the FCA’s redress scheme. The bank argued that the final proposal is “disproportionate and unfair” and contains “material flaws” .
The bank’s specific objections include:
-
Scope of the scheme: The FCA included more customer contracts in the payout scheme than originally expected .
-
Calculation methodology: The way the FCA calculated some payouts is “unsubstantiated” .
-
Hybrid redress model: The scheme introduces a hybrid compensation model that is not strictly loss-based and applies higher interest rates than initially proposed .
-
Divergence from Supreme Court ruling: FirstRand reiterated its view that the FCA scheme “significantly and inappropriately diverges” from the Supreme Court ruling .
“The group has done everything in its power to protect shareholders from a redress scheme that it considers deeply flawed in its construction and which goes against two of the FCA’s original guiding principles,” FirstRand stated .
The Business Case Collapses
FirstRand had previously warned UK regulators that should the redress scheme result in this level of provisioning, it would be forced to reconsider whether it could continue to participate in motor finance lending in the UK market .
“Given the provision amount now facing MotoNovo, the business will require further recapitalisation from the group’s existing available resources in its UK operations,” the bank said .
“This may mean financial resources available for allocation to motor finance in the UK will be severely constrained, resulting in capital not being available to fund growth in the MotoNovo business.”
While the bank acknowledged that Aldermore Bank remains a “resilient and sustainable business” with a strong management team, it concluded that “the UK as a consumer finance jurisdiction will not deliver the returns the group requires” .
Therefore, the business case for FirstRand to own and operate a UK consumer finance entity is “not within the group’s risk appetite”.
The UK Operations: Aldermore and MotoNovo
Aldermore Group
FirstRand operates in the UK through Aldermore Group, a specialist lender and savings bank that it acquired in 2017 . Aldermore was founded in 2009 by a former Barclays executive with backing from private equity firm AnaCap . The bank has a strong deposit franchise and focuses on SME lending and mortgages.
Aldermore’s standalone financial profile is solid, with group profit before tax rising 14% to £119.4 million for the first half of 2024 and a Common Equity Tier 1 (CET1) ratio of 16.2% .
MotoNovo Finance
MotoNovo is Aldermore’s motor finance arm and one of the UK’s fastest-growing independent vehicle finance companies . It commands approximately 10% market share in car finance in Britain .
The business has been at the centre of the FCA investigation. FirstRand can trace its involvement in the UK motor finance industry back to 2006, when it acquired what is now known as MotoNovo Finance from Julian Hodge Bank .
Orderly Transition
“Cognisant of protecting shareholder value and ensuring Aldermore’s future success, the group will work with the Aldermore board and respective regulators to facilitate an orderly ownership transition,” FirstRand stated .
This signals a potential sale of the UK business rather than an immediate wind-down. However, the process will need to navigate complex regulatory approvals and find a buyer willing to take on the remaining legal and regulatory risks .
The Wider Industry Context
Industry-Wide Fallout
The FCA’s redress scheme has placed several lenders under pressure across the UK. The industry is expected to pay £7.5 billion in compensation, with total programme costs estimated at £9.1 billion .
Other lenders affected include:
| Lender | Provision | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Lloyds Banking Group | ~£2 billion | Largest known provision |
| Close Brothers | ~£300 million | Under short-seller scrutiny |
| Investec | ~R678.5 million | SA lender with UK exposure |
The FCA’s Position
A spokesperson for the FCA defended the scheme, stating: “Our scheme provides certainty and is the most cost efficient and orderly way to deal with liabilities that exist, no matter what” .
The FCA noted that a record £41 billion was lent in motor finance in 2025 and that the regulator sees no further major redress events on the horizon .
What This Means for FirstRand
Capital Position Remains Strong
Despite the significant hit, FirstRand confirmed that its capital positions remain above internal targets . The group said the capital positions of FirstRand Limited, FirstRand Bank Limited, and Aldermore Group are above their respective targeted capital ratios .
Focus Returns to Core Markets
The UK exit will allow FirstRand to redirect capital and management attention to its core South African operations, which include FNB, RMB, and WesBank . The group’s South African business remains strong and profitable.
A Cautionary Tale
The FirstRand experience serves as a cautionary tale for African firms expanding into highly regulated Western markets. As one analysis noted, the decision “highlights the growing regulatory risks African firms face when expanding into highly regulated Western markets” .
Global expansion can bring both opportunity and costly regulatory exposure, even for Africa’s strongest financial players .
Key Takeaways
| Aspect | Summary |
|---|---|
| Provision | £750 million ($993 million) |
| Earnings Impact | 4-9% contraction in full-year normalised earnings |
| Decade of UK Profit | £275 million ($350 million) – provision is nearly 3x higher |
| Acquisition Price (2017) | £1.1 billion |
| Decision | Orderly exit from UK operations |
| Capital Position | Remains above internal targets |
| Dividends | Still payable, even under worst-case scenarios |
| Regulatory View | FirstRand calls scheme “disproportionate and unfair” |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Why is FirstRand exiting the UK?
FirstRand is exiting the UK after raising provisions for mis-sold car loans to £750 million ($993 million). The bank called the FCA’s redress scheme “disproportionate and unfair” and concluded that the UK consumer finance jurisdiction will not deliver the returns the group requires .
2. How much has FirstRand set aside for the motor finance scandal?
FirstRand has raised its provision to £750 million (approximately $993 million or R17.7 billion) .
3. What is the motor finance scandal about?
The scandal involves undisclosed commission payments made by lenders to car dealers between 2007 and 2024. The FCA found that these commissions were not properly disclosed to customers, and in some cases, the commissions were as high as 55% of the total charge for credit .
4. How does the provision compare to FirstRand’s UK profits?
The £750 million provision is almost three times higher than the £275 million of profits the group extracted from motor finance activities over a decade of lending in the UK .
5. Will FirstRand still pay dividends?
Yes. FirstRand maintained that it would still be able to pay dividends, even under worst-case scenarios .
6. What happens to Aldermore and MotoNovo?
FirstRand will work with the Aldermore board and regulators to facilitate an “orderly ownership transition,” signalling a potential sale of the UK business .
7. Is FirstRand’s capital position at risk?
No. FirstRand confirmed that its capital positions remain above internal targets .
8. How has the FCA responded to FirstRand’s criticism?
The FCA defended its scheme, stating that it provides “certainty” and is the “most cost efficient and orderly way to deal with liabilities that exist” .
9. What other lenders are affected by the scandal?
Lloyds Banking Group (provision of ~£2 billion), Close Brothers (~£300 million), and Investec (R678.5 million) are among the lenders affected .
10. When will FirstRand provide further clarity?
The group is expected to provide further details when it releases its audited financial results for the full year to 30 June 2026 on 10 September .
Conclusion: A Strategic Retreat
FirstRand’s decision to exit the UK marks the end of a nearly two-decade presence in the British motor finance market. The bank’s experience demonstrates that even Africa’s most sophisticated financial institutions are not immune to the regulatory risks of operating in highly developed Western markets.
The £750 million provision—nearly three times the profit the business generated over a decade—has fundamentally altered the risk-reward calculus. While Aldermore remains a viable business, FirstRand has concluded that the returns are no longer worth the regulatory exposure.
The bank will now focus on its core South African operations, where it remains one of the continent’s most valuable financial institutions. The orderly transition of Aldermore to new ownership will be closely watched by investors and regulators alike.
For now, FirstRand’s retreat serves as a powerful reminder that global expansion carries risks that can dwarf the potential rewards—even for Africa’s strongest financial players .
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Why is FirstRand exiting the UK?
FirstRand is exiting the UK after raising provisions for mis-sold car loans to £750 million ($993 million), calling the FCA’s redress scheme “disproportionate and unfair” .
2. How much has FirstRand set aside for the motor finance scandal?
£750 million (approximately $993 million or R17.7 billion) .
3. What is the motor finance scandal about?
Undisclosed commission payments made by lenders to car dealers between 2007 and 2024, with some commissions as high as 55% of the total charge for credit .
4. How does the provision compare to FirstRand’s UK profits?
The provision is almost three times higher than the £275 million of profits the group made over a decade of motor lending in the UK .
5. Will FirstRand still pay dividends?
Yes, even under worst-case scenarios .
6. What happens to Aldermore and MotoNovo?
FirstRand will facilitate an “orderly ownership transition,” signalling a potential sale .
7. Is FirstRand’s capital position at risk?
No. Capital positions remain above internal targets .
8. How has the FCA responded to FirstRand’s criticism?
The FCA defended its scheme as providing “certainty” and being the “most cost efficient and orderly way” to deal with the liabilities .
9. What other lenders are affected by the scandal?
Lloyds (~£2 billion), Close Brothers (~£300 million), and Investec (R678.5 million) .
10. When will FirstRand provide further clarity?
When it releases audited financial results for the year ending 30 June 2026 on 10 September
Source: Accra Street Journal
Last Updated on April 7, 2026 by Samuel Kwame Boadu
Disclaimer: Some content on Accra Street Journal may be aggregated, summarized, or edited from third-party sources for informational purposes. Images and media are used under fair use or royalty-free licenses. Accra Street Journal is a subsidiary of SamBoad Publishing Hub under SamBoad Business Group Ltd, registered in Ghana since 2014.
For concerns or inquiries, please visit our Privacy Policy or Contact Page.
Samuel Kwame Boadu is a Ghanaian media entrepreneur and storyteller with a passion for amplifying urban voices and uncovering everyday truths. He is the Editor-in-Chief and Founder of Accra Street Journal, a dynamic digital platform dedicated to capturing the pulse of Ghana’s capital—its people, culture, challenges, business, sports and innovations.
