LA DADEKOTOPON YOUTH ASSOCIATION v NII KPOBI TETTEY TSURU III AND 19 OTHERS

LA DADEKOTOPON YOUTH ASSOCIATION v NII KPOBI TETTEY TSURU III AND 19 OTHERS

Sponsored

Apex Insurance Brokers

 


6 min read

Case Introduction

The Supreme Court of Ghana has brought an end to a lengthy procedural chapter in the long-running dispute over the management of La Pleasure Beach in Accra. In a unanimous decision delivered on 4 November 2026, a five-member panel dismissed an appeal by Edmund Joseph Obodai Mensah, who challenged the Court of Appeal’s selection of three individuals to represent the La Dadekotopon Youth Association on the beach’s Interim Management Committee. The Court held that the appellant failed to show that the Court of Appeal exercised its discretion improperly, and further found that the challenge to the authority of the Association’s representative was barred by res judicata and that the allegation of forgery could not be sustained.

Case Overview

Court Supreme Court of Ghana
Panel Justices Tanko Amadu (presiding), E. Yonny Kulendi, E. Y. Gaewu, H. Kwofie, and J. Bartels-Kodwo
Appellant Edmund Joseph Obodai Mensah
Respondents Nii Kpobi Tettey Tsuru III and 19 Others
Date of Judgment 4 November 2026
Citation La Dadekotopon Youth Association v. Nii Kpobi Tettey Tsuru III & 19 Ors (Supreme Court, 4 November 2026)
Prior Decision Court of Appeal, 23 October 2023

Background Facts

The litigation originates from a dispute dating back to 2001 regarding the management of La Pleasure Beach, a recreational facility operated by the Ghana Tourism Development Company (GTDC). In 2001, youth of the La community expressed dissatisfaction with how the beach was being managed.

✦

Key Takeaways

  • The Supreme Court of Ghana has brought an end to a lengthy procedural chapter in the long-running dispute over the management of La Pleasure Beach in Accra.
  • The litigation originates from a dispute dating back to 2001 regarding the management of La Pleasure Beach, a recreational facility operated by the Ghana Tourism Development Company (GTDC).
  • Turqui & Brothers [2001–2002] SCGLR 498 and Anyetey Chantey v Tei Kwablah Kweinor [2020] GHASC 19, holding that the appellant could not relitigate an issue determined against him in earlier proceedings.

In April 2002, a Memorandum of Understanding was executed between the Ministry of Tourism and the La Traditional Council, providing for a management committee comprising representatives of the people of La and the GTDC. The arrangement, however, was not implemented as envisaged, prompting the La Dadekotopon Youth Association to commence litigation in 2012.

The Association sought recognition of its entitlement to participate in the beach’s management, an account of revenue generated between 2003 and 30 November 2011, and orders for the constitution of a management committee. On 21 October 2014, the High Court directed the establishment of an Interim Management Committee pending determination of the substantive dispute.

The matter reached the Court of Appeal, which on 21 July 2022 ordered the constitution of a nine-member committee with three representatives each from the La Dadekotopon Youth Association, the La Traditional Council, and the GTDC. While the Traditional Council and GTDC submitted their nominees, disagreements arose within the Association over who was entitled to represent it.

ADWUMAFIE JOB JOB OPPORTUNITY
Insurance Sales Agent (Commission-Based) – miLife Insurance Company Limited
miLife Insurance Company Limited · Ghana · Freelance
Powered by Adwumafie View Job →

Three competing groups presented different nominations. On 23 October 2023, the Court of Appeal accepted the names submitted by one group—Stanley Anyetei Nunoo, Emmanuel Nii Tagoe, and Alfred Martey—prompting the appellant, Edmund Joseph Obodai Mensah, to appeal to the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues

The Supreme Court was called upon to determine:

  1. Whether the Court of Appeal exercised its discretion improperly in selecting the three nominees to represent the La Dadekotopon Youth Association on the Interim Management Committee.

  2. Whether the appellant was estopped by the principle of res judicata from challenging the authority of Stanley Anyetei Nunoo to act for the Association.

  3. Whether the allegation that Mr. Nunoo forged signatures at the Registrar of Companies could be entertained in the proceedings.

Holding and Reasoning

Discretionary Power of the Court of Appeal

Delivering the judgment, Justice Tanko Amadu framed the central question as not whether the Supreme Court would have selected the same representatives, but whether the Court of Appeal had exercised its discretion improperly. The Court reaffirmed the settled principle that an appellate court will not interfere with a lower court’s discretionary decision unless it is shown that the discretion was exercised on a wrong principle, arbitrarily, or without sufficient justification. The Court found no basis for such interference, noting that the Court of Appeal had been confronted with competing nominations and had to resolve the immediate difficulty preventing the constitution of the Interim Management Committee.

Res Judicata on Mr. Nunoo’s Authority

Sponsored

feezeka

The Supreme Court further held that the appellant was estopped from challenging Mr. Nunoo’s mandate to act for the Association. The Court noted that the very proposition—that Mr. Nunoo had no authority to act for the La Dadekotopon Youth Association—had been litigated between the same parties and decided against the appellant in the substantive appeal. On 21 July 2022, the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal on grounds including that the trial judge erred in holding the plaintiff had capacity and that its sole witness had the mandate to testify; the appellant did not appeal that judgment to the Supreme Court. The Court applied the doctrine of issue estoppel, citing Dahabieh v S.A. Turqui & Brothers [2001–2002] SCGLR 498 and Anyetey Chantey v Tei Kwablah Kweinor [2020] GHASC 19, holding that the appellant could not relitigate an issue determined against him in earlier proceedings.

Allegation of Forgery

Sponsored

Regarding the appellant’s allegation that Mr. Nunoo “surreptitiously forged the signatures” of Jonas Obodai Torto and Shadrack Torto at the Registrar of Companies, the Court noted that this was an allegation of crime made against a person who was not a party to the appeal and had no opportunity to answer it. Section 13(1) of the Evidence Act, 1975 (NRCD 323) requires proof beyond reasonable doubt for the commission of a crime directly in issue in a civil action. Citing Fenuku and Another v John-Teye and Another [2001–2002] SCGLR 985, the Court held that such a burden is not discharged by assertion in a statement of case; it requires particularised pleading and strict proof at trial, with the accused person present and able to meet the charge. The Court also observed an inconsistency in the appellant’s position: he relied on the company profile filed at the Registrar of Companies as of 28 July 2022 to establish who the Executive Council members were, yet asked the Court to disregard the company profile of 27 September 2022 as a forgery.

Final Orders

The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal. The Court affirmed the Court of Appeal’s ruling of 23 October 2023, which approved the three representatives—Stanley Anyetei Nunoo, Emmanuel Nii Tagoe, and Alfred Martey—nominated on behalf of the La Dadekotopon Youth Association to serve on the Interim Management Committee.

Legal Significance

This decision reinforces several enduring principles of Ghanaian civil procedure and appellate practice. First, it reaffirms the high threshold for appellate interference with a lower court’s exercise of discretion—a principle deeply embedded in Ghanaian jurisprudence that promotes finality and respects the trial court’s proximity to the facts. Second, the judgment provides a clear application of issue estoppel in the context of interlocutory proceedings, demonstrating that parties cannot circumvent final judgments by raising the same substantive issue in a different procedural form. Third, the Court’s treatment of the forgery allegation underscores the strict evidentiary standard required when criminal conduct is asserted in civil proceedings: mere averments in a statement of case are insufficient, and the accused must be afforded a proper opportunity to answer the charge. Finally, the decision brings a measure of procedural closure to a dispute that has lingered for over a decade, allowing the Interim Management Committee to function with the representation the Court of Appeal had approved.

Source: Accra Legal Journal

Last Updated on November 22, 2026 by Samuel Kwame Boadu

🏢
ASJ COMPANY INTELLIGENCE Know the Companies Behind the Headlines Search Ghana's business database.
EXPLORE →
📍
ACCRA STREET DIRECTORY Find It. List It. Discover Accra. Find local businesses or get your business discovered.
EXPLORE →
ACCRA STREET JOURNAL | MARKET INTELLIGENCE

Ghana Market Watch

Track Ghana’s economy and financial markets with exchange rates, bank rates, fuel prices, food and commodity prices, economic indicators and financial market updates.

Explore Ghana Market Watch →
✅ Others are getting FREE JOBS + TIPS on our WhatsApp channel. Join now!

Disclaimer: Some content on Accra Street Journal may be aggregated, summarized, or edited from third-party sources for informational purposes. Images and media are used under fair use or royalty-free licenses. Accra Street Journal is a subsidiary of SamBoad Publishing Hub under SamBoad Business Group Ltd, registered in Ghana since 2014.

For concerns or inquiries, please visit our Privacy Policy or Contact Page.

Cite This Article

Use the following reference when citing or referencing this article.

Sponsored

SAMBOAD

Author Samuel Kwame Boadu
Published November 22, 2026
Publisher Accra Street Journal
JOBS + DIRECT ARTICLES Get job opportunities and read ASJ articles directly on WhatsApp.
Join WhatsApp Channel
Was this article helpful?

Your feedback helps us improve our journalism.

Report an Error

Help us maintain accuracy. Let our editorial team know if you spot an issue in this article.

Report a problem with this article

Your report is sent privately to the Accra Street Journal editorial team.

Sponsored

error: Content is protected. Kindly credit Accra Street Journal when referencing.
ASJ FOOTBALL
Loading scores…
Loading live matches…
Loading today's fixtures…
Loading today's results…